Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Saturday, May 1, 2010

Does 'Freedom' ipso facto mean less government?

Interesting argument; counter-arguments after the link...

 

If freedom involves having a decent set of alternatives available to us, then government action can enhance our freedom even if it involves restraints on conduct that would not otherwise violate anyone’s rights. Consider traffic laws. Those of us who drive are constantly subjected to government dictates telling us what we can and cannot do. We can only drive on one side of the street. We have to stop at red lights and stop signs even when no one else is around. If freedom means only that government should not tell us what to do, then the traffic laws are a massive intrusion on our liberty.

I suspect that most people don’t see things that way, though. They probably agree with Elizabeth Anderson, from whom I have taken this example:

To be sure, in a state of gridlock, one has the formal freedom to choose any movement in one's opportunity set -- which amounts to being able to rock forward and back a couple of inches from bumper to bumper, getting nowhere. Some freedom!

Normally, the point of driving is to get somewhere. The traffic laws enable us to get where we are going much more quickly and safely than we would if each of us had to decide for him- or herself which side of the street to drive on. The traffic laws do not tell us where to go. They leave the choice of destination, and for that matter the decision whether to drive at all, entirely up to us. They simply tell us which side of the road to drive on, that we should stop at various points, and so forth. By taking away our freedom to drive on the left, or to blast through busy intersections, they grant us much more freedom in the form of a greatly enhanced ability to get wherever we want to go quickly and safely.

Anyone who thinks that the traffic laws enhance our freedom should acknowledge that in some cases, including this one, government action can enhance our freedom, even if that action takes the form of restrictions on what we can and cannot do. An enormous number of questions about which (other) forms of government action might enhance our freedom would remain to be answered, but the fact that some government policy involves either a more active government or new restrictions on our action would not, by itself, imply that it diminishes our freedom.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Monday, April 12, 2010

Coordination Is Hard

The key thing to understand is: governance is hard, especially in a democracy.  Fundamentally, this is because coordination is hard.

It can be very hard for even a single owner to coordinate with a dozen subordinates that each coordinate with a dozen employees in an ordinary firm to achieve a simple clear goal like making and selling a simple product at a profit. Organizations fail at this task all the time, and for thousands of different reasons.  Most new organizations attempting this fail, and most that are succeeding now will fail in a few decades.  When they fail, they will fail so badly that it will not be worth trying to save them; better to throw them away and start anew.

Once one appreciates the difficulty of coordinating even small organizations, and that bigger coordination is harder, one can see why it can be extremely difficult to manage the vaster coordination required by government.  How can ordinary citizens continue over centuries to coordinate to support interest groups that coordinate to support politicians who coordinate to approve and manage policies that empower agency heads to coordinate to manage thousands of agency employees to achieve the vague incoherent goals of many millions of citizens?

This is from a new blog I've been reading. It's worth following the link to read the whole article.

Insightful perspective on governance, and the difficulty of concerted effort to achieve anything.

The author makes the compelling point that it would be wise for us to find ways to improve the effectiveness of our government, even if we believe in less government.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Liberals and Markets, Arnold Kling

Arnold Kling takes an interesting topic and dissects it well.

Are Libertarians simply Liberals who like markets?

I've considered myself a Libertarian in many political views for a long time, and have been noticing an increasing 'leftward' slide in my general political views, except for a couple hot-button areas.

Interesting:

 

To me, government is a mechanism that diffuses and dilutes accountability. If government does something wrong, does a bureaucrat get fired? Does an agency go out of business? Do legislators suffer financial losses?

If I shop for a coat, the store is accountable to me. If government decides on a policy, my affect on that policy is at best very indirect. Will my vote be determined by that policy, or by my feelings about the elected officials based on other factors? Even if I vote on the basis of a single policy, will others vote the same way? Will the elected officials understand what the voters want? etc.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Testing Minimax Play In The Field « Cheap Talk

Does game theory have predictive power?  The place to start if you want to examine this question is the theory of zero sum games where the predictions are robust:  you play the minimax strategy:  the one that maximizes your worst-case payoff.  (This is also the unique Nash equilibrium prediction.)

The theory has some striking and counterintuitive implications.  Here’s one.  Take the game rock-scissors-paper.  The loser pays $1 to the winner.  As you would expect, the theory says each should play each strategy with 1/3 probability.  This ensures that each player is indifferent among all three strategies.

Now, for the counterintuitive part, suppose that an outsider will give you an extra 50 cents if you play rock (not a zero-sum game anymore but bear with me for a minute), regardless of the other guy’s choice.  What happens now?  You are no longer indifferent among your three strategies, so your opponent’s behavior must change.  He must now play paper with higher probability in order to reduce your incentive to play rock and restore your indifference.  Your behavior is unchanged.

Things are even weirder if we change both players’ payoffs at the same time.  Take the game matching pennies.  You and your opponent hold a penny and secretly place it with either heads or tails facing up.  If the pennies match you get $1 from your opponent.  If they don’t match you pay $1.

Fun article about game theory, incentives, and prediction.

Posted via web from johnweldon4's posterous