Showing posts with label business. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Untitled

Excellent hour long video where Don Norman talks about the business of software, and user experience.

 

 

Posted via email from johnweldon4 - posterous

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Command Hierarchies and System Resilience

It seems obvious that centralized, autocratic management hierarchies are brittle and that decentralized, democratic management hierarchies are more resilient to change.

In fascinating research from Yale, it turns out that in organisms, the more complex the organism is, the more decentralized and 'democratic' the management hierarchy is.

 

In most organisms, he says, master regulators control the activity of middle managers, which in turn govern suites of workhorse genes that carry out instructions for making proteins.

Details of the study were published online in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

As a general rule, the more complex the organism, the less autocratic and more democratic the biological networks appear to be, Gerstein says.

...

In simple “autocratic” organisms such as E. coli, there tends to be a chain of command in which regulatory genes act like generals, and subordinate molecules “downstream” follow a single superior’s instructions.

But in more complex “democratic” organisms, most of these subordinate genes co-regulate biological activity, in a sense sharing information and collaborating in governance.

Organisms that have both qualities are deemed “intermediate.”

The interactions in more democratic hierarchies lead to mutually supporting partnerships between regulators than in autocratic systems, where if one gene is inactivated, the system tends to collapse.

Amazing article.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Selecting Talent: The Upshot from 85 Years of Research - Bob Sutton

Great article by Bob Sutton on hiring.

Most remarkable to me is how unpredictable on-the-job performance can be using:

  • unstructured interviews (most common in my experience),
  • reference checks (!), and
  • job experience (!!)

 

 

The upshot of this research is that work sample tests (e.g., seeing if people can actually do key elements of a job -- if a secretary can type or a programmer can write code ), general mental ability (IQ and related tests), and structured interviews had the highest validity of all methods examined (Arun, thanks for the corrections). As Arun also suggests, Schmidt and Hunter point out that three combinations of methods that were the most powerful predictors of job performance were GMA plus a work sample test (in other words, hiring someone smart and seeing if they could do the work),  GMA plus an integrity test, and GMA plus a structured interview (but note that unstructured interviews, the way they are usually done, are weaker).

Note that this information about combinations is probably more important than the pure rank ordering, as it shows what blend of methods works best, but here is also the rank order of the 19 predictors examined, rank ordered by the validity coefficient, an indicator of how strongly the individual method is linked to performance:

1. Work sample tests (.54)

2. GMA tests ..."General mental ability" (.51)

3. Employment interviews -- structured (.51) 

4. Peer ratings (.49)

5. Job knowledge tests (.48) Test to assess how much employees know about specific aspects of the job. 

6. T & E behavioral consistency method (.45) "Based on the principle that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior. In practice, the method involves describing previous accomplishments gained through work, training, or other experience (e.g., school, community service, hobbies) and matching those accomplishments to the competencies required by the job. a method were past achievements that are thought to be important to behavior on the job are weighted and score

7. Job tryout procedure (.44) Where employees go through a trial period of doing the entire job.

8. Integrity tests (.41)  Designed to assess honesty ... I don't like them but they do appear to work. 

9. Employment interviews -- unstructured (.38)

10. Assessment centers (.37)

11. Biographical data measures(.35)

12. Conscientiousness tests (.31)  Essentially do people follow through on their promises, do what they say, and work doggedly and reliably to finish their work.

13. Reference checks (.26)

14. Job experience --years (.18)

15. T & E point method (.11)

16. Years of education (.10)

17. Interests (.10)

18. Graphology (.02) e.g., handwriting analysis.

19. Age (-01)

Certainly, this rank-ordering does not apply in every setting.  It is also important to recall that there is a lot of controversy about IQ, with many researchers now arguing that it is more malleable than previously thought. But I find it interesting to see what doesn't work very well -- years of education and age in particular. And note that unstructured interviews, although of some value, are not an especially powerful method, despite their widespread use. Interviews are strange in that people have excessive confidence in them, especially in their own abilities to pick winners and losers -- when in fact the real explanation is that most of us have poor and extremely self-serving memories.

Original Article: bobsutton.typepad.com

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Liberals and Markets, Arnold Kling

Arnold Kling takes an interesting topic and dissects it well.

Are Libertarians simply Liberals who like markets?

I've considered myself a Libertarian in many political views for a long time, and have been noticing an increasing 'leftward' slide in my general political views, except for a couple hot-button areas.

Interesting:

 

To me, government is a mechanism that diffuses and dilutes accountability. If government does something wrong, does a bureaucrat get fired? Does an agency go out of business? Do legislators suffer financial losses?

If I shop for a coat, the store is accountable to me. If government decides on a policy, my affect on that policy is at best very indirect. Will my vote be determined by that policy, or by my feelings about the elected officials based on other factors? Even if I vote on the basis of a single policy, will others vote the same way? Will the elected officials understand what the voters want? etc.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Monday, March 8, 2010

Attracting Talent, via Eric Lippert

Interesting summary of feedback by Eric Lippert, who was asking about factors that make a job description attractive (or not) to potential employees.

Factors that make a job posting attractive are:

  • Required skills
    • relevant, focused, sensible
    • emphasis on ability to learn
  • Format and style
    • well-written, self-aware, humble, enthusiastic
  • Personality and culture
    • good work-life balance
    • corporate culture and values clearly expressed
    • evidence of programming methodologies, such as “Agile Programming”
    • opportunity to work with famous industry leaders or on famous products
  • The job itself
    • described in detail: specific team, specific product, specific job
    • telecommuting possible
    • work is beneficial to industry and society
    • work has large scope -- “change the world”
    • work is challenging
    • product is innovative
    • tools/languages to be used are described and are current and familiar
    • good pay
    • autonomy to choose own tools, architectures, methodologies
    • details of the team stated – team size, for example
    • more than just typing in code – opportunities for UI design, DB design, troubleshooting user problems, and so on
via blogs.msdn.com

I highly recommend following the link and reading the whole article if you in any way participate in hiring, and/or drafting job requirements.

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous

Friday, February 26, 2010

20 (More) Reality-Checking Questions for Would-Be Entrepreneurs - The Conversation - Harvard Business Review

In addition to the 20 questions Dan Isenberg asks, ask yourself if you can answer "yes" to this list of statements before deciding whether or not to become an entrepreneur:

  1. I am willing to lose everything.
  2. I embrace failure.
  3. I am always willing to do tedious work.
  4. I can handle watching my dreams fall apart.

Well... the list starts off pretty light... I think I can do it :)

Posted via web from johnweldon4 - posterous